by Shawn Leonardo, CommanDollar Commander is a format dedicated to the unusual,the wacky, the crazy, and the occasional rules question that make judges cry themselves to sleep. The 100-card Highlander format was first geared towards multiplayer and social play, though through the support of Wizards of the Coast (via creating products for the format and taking it into consideration when designing sets), the format has taken a sharper edge.
With the release of Aether Revolt comes Exquisite Archangel, a creature that many who enjoy the format are divided on-some think this to be an auto-include in their decks, while others believe it should be struck with the almighty ban-hammer. But why? At first, Exquisite Archangel looks bland-a 5/5 flyer for a total converted mana cost of 7 isn't all that exciting. The controversy comes from the small wall of text: "If you would lose the game, instead exile Exquisite Archangel and your life total becomes your starting life total." Put into layman's terms, if this card is on a player's field and they take lethal damage, they simply remove this card from the game and start with a new buffer of life. In formats like standard, modern, etc. this may be concerning-after battling and slinging spells to eliminate your opponent from the lofty amount of twenty life, they simple reset to the start with all the board advantage intact. For commander players, however, this card is a much greater issue, as the format has a starting life total of forty. So what are the arguments for and against banning this card? Why Exquisite Archangel should be banned in Commander 1) It negates all of a player's hard work in eliminating a single opponent 2) It is a single card that can change the outcome of an entire game 3) It can be splashed in any deck with white Why Exquisite Archangel shouldn't be banned in Commander 1) It dies easily to removal 2) Higher mana cost 3) Exiles, meaning it cannot be reused multiple times 4) One-of in a 99-card deck These arguments echo similar sentiment over the years, of cards players want banned from the game due to their degenerative nature. More often than not, however, cards become banned only after they have been tried in the format, and found guilty of warping the game around themselves (we're looking at you, Primeval Titan). What are your thoughts on Exquisite Archangel? Should it be banned, or allowed to stay in the format?
0 Comments
By Shawn Leonardo, CommanDollar With Aether Revolt coming soon to a kitchen table near you, it's the perfect time to be both excited and prepared. The latest Magic: the Gathering set promises a whole new batch of fun, unique interactions that can potentially change a number of format's metagames. While it is sometimes difficult to get Commander players excited for a new set, Aether Revolt seems to have delivered on that end of the bargain, especially with its set of Legendary Creatures. Players both new to the format and experienced are bound to pick up these cards and want to bring them to their maximum potential, and the ideas below can give everyone a headstart on the process. Sram, Senior Edificer and Batterskull Draw in any mono-color besides blue makes everyone think twice , and after careful consideration it looks like Batterskull would be a Sram commander's best friend. It doesn't take any kind of deep analysis to see that Batterskull can provide you with some much-needed card draw, as well as a potential threat. While somewhat expensive already, I can forsee the price rising just a hair due to the desire for commander players. Hopefully this has inspired you to go to Gathereror some other card database and pour over the pages! Baral, Chief of Compliance and Arcane Denial Counterspells were already pretty great before Baral was spoiled. Now, cards like Dissolve are all Counterspells, meaning two open blue mana will always signify a resounding "No" while this legend is out on the field, cancelling your plans entirely. Arcane Denial becomes merely one blue mana to outwit your opponents. This cryptic command will lock down the board state as long as there is open mana, and is a wonderful option for the right control player. Foil your opponent's plans before they even get going with sheer force of will, or wait for them to make a mental misstep before profiting from your oppressive will. Rishkar, Peema Renegade and Forgotten Ancient Rishkar seemed underwhelming at first-until you notice that he turns your creatures with counters into Llanowar Elves. You could easily go into Elf tribal with this legend, however you can go in almost any direction you want with Rishkar's burst of strength. Forgotten Ancient allows you to rapidly increase your mana sources, since everyone will be playing spells as much as they can to try and keep up. Note how this card's first ability is triggered when it enters the battlefield, meaning you can find ways to flicker it, adding to both your mana base as well as an increasing savagery during combat. Once you've enjoyed the fruits of this card's natural panoply , casting as many cards as you have the mana for (which should be a lot, and quickly), the game should soon swing in your favor, and your opponents will find themselves in death's presence. A deck centered around Rishkar will certainly be a triumph of the hordes! Kari Zev, Skyship Raider and Confusion in the Ranks Red has a fatal attraction when it comes to...well, pretty much anything. As far as legends go, Kari may be the weakest amongst the Aether Revolt when it comes to being a Commander. Acting on impulse and reflexes alone won't get you far in the multiplayer format, and fortunately this article can become a useful chasm guide for you. Kari likes to work with cards like Confusion in the Ranks, swapping a tapped Ragavan for your opponent's best creature, then watching the pandemonium that ensues when they lose Ragavan and their best creature after combat ends. Use these arcane teachings to cause impact tremors in the game, and you'll have a good chance of avoiding where ancients tread. Yahenni, Undying Partisan and Dictate of Erebos Yahenni was made with some small measure of diabolic intent. With cards like Dictate of Erebos and Grave Pact, this commander becomes an abhorrent overlord, making everyone barter in blood. If your deck is not centered around creatures, you have a stronger chance; if not, the game becomes one of attrition, and you will soon eliminate the competition. There is no such thing as innocent blood in a game Commander , but with the right cards on the field this new legend becomes a merciless executioner, and one sinister concoction of a deck. Hope of Ghirapur and Whispersilk Cloak Wow! A new colorless Legendary! What a godsend! Now, what do we do with it? Attack, of course! Whispersilk Cloak is perfect for this creature, ensuring the ultimate evasion to get damage through in combat. This creature should be cast every first turn if it is your commander, to carry a blazing torch to your opponent's field. You may not be delivering any hot soup, however this card will certainly give you an infiltration lens on what your opponent's strategy is. It may not be a power house, and it may earn a glaring spotlight from your opponent(s) who are locked down, but if all your opponent can cast is creatures (locking out instants, sorceries, planeswalkers, artifacts, and enchantments), there will be more than just hope for victory. These legendary creatures all have a lot of potential for the Commander format, and players around the world are excited to get their hands on them and weild them with deadly efficiency. Prerelease for Aether Revolt is this weekend, January 14-15, and releases in stores on January 20th, 2017! ![]() Shawn Leonardo is a casual Magic: the Gathering blogger, and mainly discusses the EDH/Commander format as well as budget solutions. He currently resides in Idaho, where he plots world domination. By Shawn Leonardo, CommanDollar The concept of a New Year's resolution is that a person takes the opportunity of a fresh start, often changing an undesired trait or behavior, or attempting to grow as an individual. It is a time honored tradition that often sees people looking to lose weight, eat healthier, and spend more time with loved ones. But how does Magic: the Gathering fit into this tradition? In truth, Magic has so much room to grow and change, both as a game and as a community of players. The formats aren't perfect, the community isn't perfect, and that means we can make many resolutions together, and hold each other to them as well-after all, a major part of making a change permanent is having accountability. With this, I present to you: A Magic: the Gathering Player's 2017 Resolutions! Resolution #1: Be bold in your builds We all know what works, what's consistent, what's valuable, and what wins. There are staples for each format that make the game run smoother, from fetch lands to Command Tower , and while they don't ruin formats, they do stabilize it-or stagnate it, as some would believe. Think of your local meta-what decks are there to always meet/beat? Do they ever change? Why not take the steps to change yourself? Be bold-build a jank deck, something with budget cards that might never work, but is fun and new and different. Shake up your local meta with something out of nowhere, and inject some new life into it; there are over 16,000 cards in the game-be daring, be different, and be creative! Resolution #2: Try a new format This may be the most challenging resolution for some. They have seen and tested a number of formats, but have settled for the one(s) they enjoy the most. Fortunately, most Magic players like to make multiple decks in the formats they love for the very reason this resolution may become the easiest for you to tackle. Ask that one friend who plays Modern, or Standard, or EDH/Commander, Legacy, Vintage, Frontier, etc. to borrow a deck and learn the format. You never know what you'll discover-though your wallet may cry for the results. Resolution #3: Keep the community diverse Wizards of the Coast has made great strides in diversifying its cast within the last year or so, and it is a warming sight to see the company power forward in making sure everyone has a character they can identify with, whether it be Saheeli Rai, Narset, Alesha (my favorite EDH/Commander deck!), and others. Yet when we go to card shops to play, trade or...well, talk shop, we find the population far less diverse than our cast of characters. This may not be malicious intent on many of our part, however there are a few quick tips to keep in mind when someone new shows up to the LGS you frequent:
Magic: the Gathering is a medium between two or more people, a language in as of itself that people can speak and find friendship in. When you speak the language, you represent all those who speak the same lingo, so being a shining role model at all times is critical. Remember that when you go to your LGS, compose yourself in the way you'd like to be seen by others, and that you'll be in close quarters with these people for the majority of the night. Our community has been the target of the internet's unrelenting barrage due to concerns of hygiene and appearance, and while one can argue that they should feel entirely comfortable in their LGS, others would argue the same for everyone. Know that if you come presenting your best self, nobody stands to lose. This doesn't only apply to appearance, however. Attitude and behavior are just as critical of components to having a fun experience as dress and hygiene. Many players can recall facing someone who was a sore loser-or a sore winner-souring the mood and even at times deterring players from returning, at threat of a repeated incident. Keep in mind that you're playing a game, and that it is only the medium to the person or people across the table; they will remember some plays, for sure, but they will remember more your behavior and actions throughout it. If you see someone who is being subjected to any negative behavior, from attitude to harassment to worse, have someone inform go get a store management and separate the persons involved while bringing a few more level-headed individuals to ease tensions . It takes only one negative experience for a player to give up an otherwise wonderful game, and as Edmund Burke once stated: "The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.". This applies to all of us as a community-have fun, and do good by ourselves and others. And there you have it! Four resolutions to ring in the New Year, making it all the better with your influence. Keep to these resolutions, and hold others to these standards, and watch the community you love grow to something even greater than it is now. Draw well, and Happy New Year everyone! ![]() Shawn Leonardo is a casual Magic: the Gathering blogger, and mainly discusses the EDH/Commander format as well as budget solutions. He currently resides in Idaho, where he plots world domination. By Shawn Leonardo, CommanDollar Now that Battle for Zendikar has been out for a while, prices and expectations have stabilized for the set-especially with Oath of the Gatewatch currently morphing the formats. One card has surprisingly dropped off the radar, however. Despite Sire of Stagnation's decent stats and menacing ability, it's being found in dollar rare bins everywhere; before Battle came out, it was a $15 card-but why?
A card's value typically stabilizes around how often it is seen played in competitive decks. The only deck currently running it is a standard four-color Eldrazi ramp. It's not seeing solid play in any other competitive format so far, which explains the sheer drop in value. For EDH/Commander players, however, picking a copy(or more) of this monstrosity up may be a great idea, because chances are the value of this card will skyrocket in the long run and bolster your binder. When Consecrated Sphinx was spoiled and finally released in Mirrodin Besieged, it was valued at around $6. While there have been some dips back down to around that number, Sphinx has been slowly yet steadily on the rise, and currently sits at around $23-and what it does is incredible. In a 1v1 game, Sphinx nets you two extra cards on your opponent's turn and has evasion, making it useful for combat as well. In a multiplayer game, Sphinx can be the devastating cascade for a player to win the game, drawing an insane amount of cards for the investment of 6 mana. How does Sphinx compare to Sire, though? By all accounts, Sire puts in more work for the investment in Dimir (U/B) rather than just blue-which may also attribute to its low price. Everyone typically has to draw a card during their turn, which will net you two cards of your own with Sphinx-but playing land is a voluntary necessity, and the steep cost Sire makes players pay will make them think twice, watching their deck wither away at the price of trying to win the game. Late-game mana drops for your opponent(s) become painful as their decks begin vanishing right before their eyes. This kind of low-key control strikes fear into players desperately trying to get more mana. You also net two extra cards from their land drop, giving you a distinct and substantial advantage. Considering that their converted mana cost is the same(though Sire requires U/B rather than UU), and Sire's stats are better(a 5/7 compared to Sphinx's 4/6), which only balances out because Sphinx has evasion, Sire's level up is that it exiles two cards off the top of your opponent's library, milling them while you gain card advantage. No need to scry or delve into the issue further-if you're running U/B in EDH/Commander, grab a couple of these now while they're cheap, before a frenzy for them drives up the price! By Shawn Leonardo, CommanDollar ![]() As of recently, and according to Wizards Play Network policy, *no* proxies are allowed at WPN-sanctioned venues, regardless of whether the event is sanctioned or not. That means: • Magic events (sanctioned and unsanctioned) can only allow genuine Magic: The Gathering cards. • Proxy cards are substitute cards created solely by judges in sanctioned tournaments pursuant to the official tournament rules. These substitutes are allowed when authorized game cards become unplayable during a sanctioned tournament because of damage or excessive wear. • Counterfeit cards are copies or reproductions of actual Wizards trading cards, whether or not they are identified as non-genuine. The creation and distribution of counterfeits violate United States and international copyright laws and negatively affects the integrity of Wizards’ trading card games. Counterfeits are strictly prohibited, even for personal, non-commercial use. While this will affect mainly Vintage and Legacy players, EDH/Commander players may also feel the heat. As an eternal format, giving players access to all cards that have been printed (besides those cards on the ban list) is part of the joy and appeal. Is this update on policy good, bad, or somewhere in the middle? Why it’s bad for Wizards of the Coast Part of the appeal of playing Magic: the Gathering is the wide spread of players, formats, and cards you can utilize. As you go further back into MtG cardboard history, it becomes increasingly more difficult to obtain cards due to rarity, price, collections, and other means. That means new players will likely not have access to these rare and often powerful cards. Most stores have accepted this, especially for Legacy and Vintage, allowing a certain number of cards to be proxied to balance the scales. Without the ability to use proxies, Legacy and Vintage tournaments may disappear altogether, becoming a fossil of ancient times, and slashing the value of those cards due to lack of use. Why it’s bad for the Players As said before, having access to cards like dual lands can severely put you behind in certain formats; proxies are needed just to keep up with the pace. Now, in order to play, you need to truly commit-either own copies of the cards you need, borrow them from a friend, or even rent them, rather than quickly searching to find a decent image and print/sleeve them. Why it’s good for Wizards of the Coast Perhaps WotC is trying to kill its older formats; it’s like that strange old man that comes around stroking his beard, saying “Hmm…” and then moving on to scrutinize someone else-rarely do we know what goes on and is discussed behind closed doors. While something tells me they aren’t too worried about the secondary/third markets on their product, the overall concern may be a longer-term problem-the Reserved List (as if there wasn’t enough controversy here already). For example, all the dual lands are on the list for a reason-they are extremely powerful to the point where the game can warp around them. Every card on the list was likely put there because it as viewed as a “mistake” of sorts, being too powerful for the set or Magic overall, in an attempt to dramatically slow Power Creep, as making cards of that sort would bring ruin to the game at an unmanageable pace. Why it’s good for the Players A few months ago, we published an article on how using proxies is harmful to both the player and the game. It garnished a lot of negative responses, with the words “elitist” and “classist” being used as often as bullets in a minigun. The proxy debate walks quite a fine line there; however, the answer does come down to money. Magic: the Gathering is a pay-to-play game, and there is little substance to have any illusions about it. With WotC now pumping out more sets per year than before, and the constant rotation of Standard, their main pull where most new players begin at, it does require taking money out of your pocket and putting it in theirs. Some people do get lucky; having a friend who just gives/sells you their cards, finding a collection at a garage sale, or some other means. Others, mainly new players or those who wish to enter a different format, are often left in the dust. How is this good for the players? I often think back to my college days, where in my playgroup we had one friend who would have to borrow a deck from someone. Not because he didn’t have the means to build a deck-he had been collecting since elementary school-but because his one and only “deck” was entirely proxied Riku of Two Reflections combo deck priced in the thousands. Unanimously, we told him he couldn’t play that deck with us; every single other player had decks without a single proxy in it, and it wasn’t fair in the slightest. This came when I was new to EDH/Commander as a format, where building a deck was hard, took time and investing in buying/trading/pulling good from packs. It would have been far simpler for me to proxy a $1000+ deck and beat every other player time after time-but I didn’t. I valued what little I had, and slowly worked my way towards the decks I have today(which still often get taken apart and rebuilt on some regular basis). The difference is in work, and fairness. It takes time and work in order to build a deck to the means you want it; it may take weeks, months or years and sometimes even money to “finish” a deck, while printing a deck out takes a few minutes and whatever pittance the printer asks. Yes, it takes time to earn something powerful and useful-which is the entire purpose of something powerful and useful. Why do we have a stake in this? As a blog all about the community, and playing/having fun on a budget, why should we not wholeheartedly support players proxying cards, if not whole decks in order to save money? The short answer is that we in our own way support when Wizards is doing a good job; the long answer is that we support the players’ growth. If the clear-cut banning of proxy cards has you upset because of limitations it has placed on you, my response is clear: overcome those limitations, or don’t. It may take time, it may take money, it may be frustrating-but if it’s worth it to you, then it will be worth it to you. The true value of this game is in the interaction between people and cards, however it is all about what you want. For those who still wish to play with proxies, there is honestly nothing stopping you from doing so at the most important battleground-the kitchen table. Only glory and stories for future gatherings are at stake there, and the scales can be evenly stacked to everyone’s liking. If not being able to use a proxy card because it’s worth $400 (and you would never pay/trade/come into luck with that) causes you to get upset, think of how someone who would sit across from you, having taken the time or money or trading to get that card would feel when you play a proxy version. All that effort that they had taken to obtain such a rare and valuable piece to their deck was printed out for 10 cents in under a minute. Now, that is something to get upset about, especially when anything is on the line (planeswalker points, qualifiers, prizes, etc.). As someone who has played Magic on and off(mostly on) for for thirteen years now, I am still nowhere close to making that kind of investment on a card. I likely never will-I’m a budget player at heart, and I’d rather play with a Mountain or an Island than a Volcanic Island, which is easier, more fun for me, and is the whole philosophy of this blog. I also encourage everyone to do the same reason: While WotC may be trying to squeeze every nickel and dime it can out of players, you save TONS of money while still having TONS of fun with what cards you may already have collecting dust in a box or bargain bin. You may think you limit is how much you can spend, or print; I say, your limit is in your creativity, imagination, and willingness to try. So, proxies be damned, and long live the budget options. ![]() Shawn is a casual Magic: the Gathering blogger, and mainly discusses the EDH/Commander format as well as budget solutions. He resides in northern New Jersey, where he plots world domination. *This article was previously posted on Tumblr by CommanDollar.
Millstone Revised artwork by Kaja Foglio The game of Magic is incredibly diverse-from the amount of zones cards can be placed in, to the types of cards, and the strategies that place cards from one zone to another. One of those strategies is “milling”-putting cards directly from your opponent’s deck into their graveyard. The name comes from that of the card Millstone, one of the first cards with the ability. With around 200 cards that could aid you in winning the game, this alternate win condition has the support needed to take the gold. This strategy is difficult to utilize in its entirety, however the results can alter the game tremendously. Through the denial of resources and the unique specific strategy, mill is a viable method. However, beware-its power is great, and not the most well received! Glimpse the Unthinkable artwork by Brandon Kitkouski The Denial of Resources Mill typically appears in the colors blue and black (though it does make an appearance with green!)-control, denial and having the majority of interaction with graveyards. Blue is best known for its ability to counter cards coming into play. Milling, therefore, could be seen as a form of “advanced countering”-stopping a spell before it’s even cast, by denying the card itself from its owner’s hand. While both blue and black seem to prefer responding to threats, in this special case there is already an advanced plan on how to handle them. Hedron Crab artwork by Jesper Ejsing The Advanced Strategy In most formats, everyone starts at 20 life; Tiny Leaders is 25, Pauper Commander is 30, and EDH/Commander is 40. When you primarily play mill, however, the numbers skyrocket. 20 becomes 60, 25 becomes 49, and 30/40 become 99-the amount of cards in your opponent’s library. Mill works best en masse-cards like Archive Trap, Consuming Aberration, Increasing Confusion, and Mind Grind are amazing. While those big spells are hitting, smaller mill cards that chip away pieces such as Dreamborn Muse, Grindclock, Curse of the Bloody Tome, and Memory Erosion will quickly make an opponent’s graveyard taller than their deck. Mirko Vosk, Mind Drinker artwork by Chase Stone The Uphill Battle Combat becomes tricky, as some creatures need to deal combat damage in order to deal the real damage you want. Mirko Vosk, Mind Drinker, for example, has a devastating mill ability-if it connects with your opponent’s life. Granted, blue and black have plenty of evasion built into the colors, yet putting those in may end up convoluting the strategy. Cards like Elixir of Immortality or any of the three Eldrazi Titans (Ulamog, Emrakul, and Kozilek) can completely reset the alternate life total. These factors definitely play a part in the lower visibility of mill as a strategy compared to others. Increasing Confusion artwork by Dan Scott The After-Game Mill is absolutely an advanced strategy-more so in a multiplayer format. Similar to Poison/Infect, once the overall plan is realized, players take preventative measures to ensure they don’t fall victim, simultaneously painting a target on the would-be miller’s head. If someone does get milled out, chances are they will be the next player to go. From the opposite side of the table, being a player targeted for a slow, mill-ful death is agonizing and typically demoralizing for the amount of fun you can have in the game (unless your deck revolves around having stuff in the graveyard-then you’re about to have a blast!). The low amount of interaction that can occur when a mill player gets what they need early enough to prevent someone else from playing also tends to leave opponents feeling unsatisfied. Keeing Stone artwork by Jung Park The Last Card Mill requires patience, and a mutual understanding by the rest of the players that, while an effective strategy, may not be as enjoyable for the opponents. As a strategy, it’s not the most competitive-combat in mill is lackluster at best, and life totals for the strategy can be triple of what they normally are. Multiple players also increase the amount of difficulty several times over. Relying on it as the only plan of attack can and will get you killed off, which requires diluting the amount of mill played in order to survive long enough to move the millstone. Both difficult and dangerous, mill is an option only for those up to the task. It’s certainly not for those new to the game-to play or play against!-so play with caution when it comes to mill, commanders. This was originally posted on Tumblr by CommanDollar ![]() Shawn Leonardo is a casual Magic: the Gathering blogger, and mainly discusses the EDH/Commander format as well as budget solutions. He resides in northern New Jersey, where he plots world domination. by Shawn Leonardo, CommanDollar Skithiryx, the Blight Dragon Artwork by Chippy EDH/Commander is well known for it’s lengthy multiplayer games, lasting hours due to large deck size, eternal turns, and large amount of starting life total. However, poison and Infect, a mechanic primarily in the reduced the life total necessary from 40 (or 20) down to 10, cutting the amount of damage needed to be done dramatically. The mechanic Proliferate in Scars of Mirrodin block was also a large contributor, yet the source is the poison. The rules committee has not changed that; in EDH/Commander, it is still 10 poison counters to lose the game. Blightsteel Colossus Artwork by Christ Rahn The big question is: why hasn’t this changed? After asking the community, it seems that it’s split. With cards like Blightsteel Colossus, which can be placed in any deck and is a one-shot kill, it’s difficult to grasp why the total for poison counters hasn’t been raised to half the life total. The answer may be in the game itself, however. The ways to lose in a game of EDH are as such: being at 0 life, being unable to draw a card from your deck, having 10 poison counters, and having 21 commander damage from a single commander in the game. The varying ways to achieve victory are part of the diversity of the game, and the only reason Infect is played. If Infect was raised to 20 (half the starting life total, which may be the intent of the mechanic’s design), it would be only 1 damage away from being commander damage. That would turn some players away from using Infect, and taking away from the diversity of the format. Glistening Oil Artwork by Steven Belledin Another aspect to consider is the multiplayer foundation of EDH/Commander. When a player starts using infect in a four-player game, the other three can clearly see the threat potential, and typically treat it much as we treat an infection: by cleaning it out. There may be one or even two players who get knocked out via Infect in the game, through a single-shot creature, Triumph of the Hordes or another means, but that’s perfectly alright-the game goes quicker and the other players now know better than to trust the deck when that mana is open. TL;DR It's clear that the Rules Committee might never up the amount of poison counters needed to lose in EDH/Commander. It diversifies the game, allows other cards to be played and strategies to be used, and gives players the chance to learn and experience a new strategy in a very large format. Long live the 10; may it compleat you and your game. ![]() Shawn Leonardo is a casual Magic: the Gathering blogger, and mainly discusses the EDH/Commander format as well as budget solutions. He resides in northern New Jersey, where he plots world domination. One of my favorite cards from the recent Battle for Zendikar set is From Beyond, an enchantment that spawns Scion tokens. While definitively a spitting image of Awakening Zone from Rise of the Eldrazi, it makes you question: which is better? It all depends on the play style. Both enchantments offer you tokens that can be sacrificed for a colorless mana each, ramping you just a little more each turn. However, there the similarities end. Awakening Zone can be played one turn earlier than From Beyond, giving you a quicker boost in mana/ramp. The trade is that you get 0/1 Spawn, leaving you no real option other than to use as chump blockers or for their mana. From Beyond, while more expensive, seems to be far more versatile. That one extra mana gives you tokens with 1 power, making up for the lack of power that Zone has. The extra sacrifice ability on the bottom of Beyond is also enormous-rather than losing so much to a simple Naturalize, you can pay the 1G (and get a colorless from one of your Scions!) and get any Eldrazi from your deck, be it a Blisterpod, All is Dust, Eldrazi Conscription or even Emrakul, the Aeons Torn! So, is From Beyond better than Awakening Zone? Perhaps; the more aggressive cost and simplicity of Awakening Zone may be overlooked, even left alone as a non-threat, while From Beyond can cause your opponent(s) to use a counter or removal to deal with how threatening it may be-searching. It all depends on the deck(s), the board state, and the draw. Do you believe one is truly better than the other? Comment below! ![]() Shawn Leonardo is a casual Magic: the Gathering blogger, and mainly discusses the EDH/Commander format as well as budget solutions. He resides in northern New Jersey, where he plots world domination. Propaganda artwork by Clint Cearley It’s Game Night, and your friends gather together for a night of chaos and entertainment; two games later, the night is over, everyone packs up and goes their separate ways. For those unaware of the format, only playing two games in one night sounds both grueling and boring. Why would people play a format that takes so long? If you have been skeptical or downright against playing EDH/Commander, I would recommend giving this a once-over. The EDH/Commander format is, like all other Magic: the Gathering formats, an acquired taste. There certainly are aspects of the format’s culture that can attract or repel players, though it deserves explanation before making a final judgement. I have been playing EDH/Commander since around fall of 2011. My first deck was hastily assembled with Darigaaz, the Igniter at the helm; I was also the first player removed in my first game, and that almost made me abandon the format. Obviously, I stuck with it and now enjoy a good match. But what draws a player who was at first scorned? The Singleton Strategy Unlike most formats, EDH/Commander is highlander specific-meaning that only one copy of a card aside from basic lands can be in the deck. While cards with similar effects can make their way into the 99, the sheer number of cards makes getting one specific card far more difficult-and statistically improbable-than hoping to draw one of a playset from a 60-card deck. The game becomes a longer strategic bout from that, as well as the increased life totals and pool of cards players can access. While there are staples and ban lists in all supported formats, including EDH/Commander, The 15,000+ cards and 600+ legendary creatures allow for a diverse combination to be seen at every table-and rest assured, games often do take up the whole table! Multiplayer Glory The foundation of EDH/Commander was in a social multiplayer experience, and while the typical 1-versus-1 matches (commonly known as French Commander or Duel Commander) have interest, the roots of the game grow deep. The joy of multiplayer magic comes in both inclusiveness and politics, which soon brought me back to the table, eager for another shot. Even if someone claims to “ignore politics” within a game, that itself warps the other players’ play style in the match-up. In the end, who won, who betrayed who, the fatal plays-and misplays-create an experience worth repeating. Your deck may be the sloppiest 100 pieces of paper ever assembled, yet can have the capability to claim victory, thanks to the chaos of multiplayer magicking. Also, with the incredible amount of possibilities EDH/Commander can create, each match has the potential to be unique-in the haunting words of the Hunger Games, “May the odds be ever in your favor!” Eternal Change The financial aspect that drew me back into playing EDH/Commander was the lack of rotation-something that instantly made me drop playing standard and swapping over to something more financially applicable. While decks can be worth anywhere from $20 to several thousand, you have the capability to upgrade them over time, learning strategy and deck tech along the way. Formats like standard may have decks worth slightly less, yet the rotation involved in the format makes everything add up in a shorter period of time. Trading/buying cards for EDH/Commander is often a purposeful investment, a slow but steady progression to building the deck you truly will be satisfied with-though that rarely happens. Decks are built, come apart and are rebuilt as often as a child builds with and destroys Lego sets. If someone does set in stone a deck they enjoy however, that deck can remain unchanged for as long as they wish; the rare card being banned may occur, however as stated before, the sheer volume of cards to choose from as replacement make all the difference. The Biggest Reason of All EDH/Commander is great and amazing for all the aforementioned reasons, yet there is one final piece as to why the format is incredible, though only for a small portion of the crowd. Something special. Something like getting to say… So play. To have fun, to include a massive amount of people, to have to change very little (or a lot), and to play that one card that you never could play anywhere else. Happy gaming, folks. * This post was originally published at CommanDollar on Tumblr. ![]() Shawn Leonardo is a casual Magic: the Gathering blogger, and mainly discusses the EDH/Commander format as well as budget solutions. He resides in northern New Jersey, where he plots world domination. By Shawn Leonardo, CommanDollar Every now and then, when sounding the call (”who wants to play some EDH?”), someone asks “What’s E-D-H?”; that question throws it back to before the summer of 2011, when Elder Dragon Highlander was taking its first few steps towards becoming the format we all love-or hate. What was it like back in the old days? Were they the Golden Years of EDH, or are we experiencing that now? We’ll briefly take a look at how it was in the beginning, how the format has changed, and the potential positive/negative aspects of its evolution from a fan format to a Wizards of the Coast-supported format. The Early Days No Command Tower. No Opal Palace. No Kaalia of the Vast. No Oloro. In the beginning, there was no product, no guidance, no meta. And the creators said, “Play anything; Play everything”. And so it was, and it was good. Elder Dragon Highlander was born out of a desire for a more casual, social/multiplayer way to play Magic: the Gathering, likely whilst using cards you would never otherwise use. A haven for the Timmy’s of the world, playing cards such as Greater Gargadon and other cards that had a high converted mana cost (CMC) was encouraged due to the high life total and typical length of games. The Onset of Commander Eventually the format started appearing at tournaments, with players like Sheldon Menery bringing it to Pro Tours, and Wizards of the Coast saw the potential, and in June of 2011 the first product, called Commander, was released. Five different preconstructed decks slammed onto tables across the globe, with brand-new cards and generals nobody had ever seen before included. Fairly well tuned and incredible in raw power, these decks swept through kitchen tables, upping the challenge the format posed. Now, rather than simply throwing cards that matched the color identity of the general you happened to have lying around, the edge of your metaphorical stick began to get sharpened-the format taking its first major steps towards a meta, as well as seeing more product in the future. Four and a half years, and two (soon to be three) products later, Commander is as easy to find players for as any of the other WotC-supported formats; The Rules Committee silently lurks, watching the online meta to bring relative balance to the format, and Wizards now takes into account how cards will be utilized in our beloved format when creating sets. We see many cards now hitting each opponent rather than just a single target opponent. But is that a good thing? The Good For those who play/have played Tiny Leaders, they know that it may never get the support that EDH did due to lack of traction and popularity. Had EDH never gotten a product out, it may not have evolved into what we all enjoy (or despise), and we may not even be playing it at all. While it’s uncertain if WotC took a calculated risk when creating and releasing the first Commander decks, their entrance into the stage of the game certainly upped the ante on how it would be played. Similarly, releasing new pre-con decks gets players new and old interested in the format. Rather than having to go home and build a deck, they can buy a “starter deck” for the format, and morph it to something more desirable. New cards come with each release, prompting collectors and players alike to buy decks, only to devour it for a few cards they could use to level up their current decks. EDH/Commander is an eternal format-there’s no rotation, and very rarely does the mighty Rules Committee come out and ban/un-ban cards. Even if they do, house rules are mightier around the kitchen table; though if someone wants to run Griselbrand as a commander, watch out! The Bad While still considered a casual format, nobody can deny the power creep that has come into the game-something that was unavoidable with the support WotC provided. The format has become far more competitive; what started out as a six-shooter turned into an Uzi, then a cannon, and now a submarine carrying nuclear payloads. Prices of common “staple” cards used in the format have gone up, making it more difficult to get into. Net decking, while not necessarily a bad thing, has become more prevalent in searching for how to make a deck/commander more efficient. Just as the wild west evolved into part of the United States, so has EDH evolved into Commander. WotC swings hard for the format; sometimes it’s a home run, while other times it’s striking out. Cards such as Griselbrand, Worldfire, and Sylvan Primordial were experiments likely designed to give Commander players even more support; the Primordials were meant to replace the Titans, especially Prime Time, who had recently gotten ban-hammered. Looking at all these names on the ban list, you can tell they didn’t work out. What they did do, however (in addition to the first Commander product) was show Wizards where how far they could go before they break the wheel. In the End How the format has changed over the years has been in no small part due to players doing what they do best-playing. Uncountable hours spent testing, searching and building has resulted in a greater understanding of the game and how incredible it really is. Just as life is, the nature of the format is to change, grow and expand over time, otherwise the same decks would exist with the same meta, creating a boring format which would eventually fall out of interest. The continuing product support and cards in sets allow Commander to constantly shift, keeping players on their feet for new opportunities to improve and play. So, if you ever sound the call and someone asks “What’s E-D-H?”, don’t be afraid to tell them of the times before support, when the cards that would land on the table could be anything and every game was completely different-like today, but far more wild. ![]() Shawn Leonardo is a casual Magic: the Gathering blogger, and mainly discusses the EDH/Commander format as well as budget solutions. He currently resides in Idaho, where he plots world domination. |
Keep up with the latest Magic the Gathering and other gaming articles by subscribing below:
FEATURED CONTRIBUTORS
OWNER
Lyn Lomasi is founder and owner of the Brand Shamans Content Community. Services include ordained soul therapy and healing ministry, business success coaching, business success services, handcrafted healing jewelry, ethereal and anointing oils, altar and spiritual supplies and services, handcrafted healing beauty products, and more!
Lyn is your brand healing, soul healing, marketing & content superhero to the rescue! While rescuing civilians from boring business practices and energy vampires, this awesomely crazy family conquers evil and creates change. They live among tigers, dragons, mermaids, unicorns, and other fantastic energies, teaching others to claim their own power and do the same. By supporting us, you support a dedicated parent, healer, and minority small business that donates to several causes. Profits from our all-inclusive store, Intent-sive Nature support these causes and our beautiful family! HIRE OR SHOP WITH LYN | CONTACT LYN Archives
August 2022
Categories
All
|